The
short story, Girl, reminds me of the
movie “Their Eyes Were Watching God”. In the short story, the mother is giving
her daughter a list of different rules and customs that she must follow in
order to become a young lady; so that her daughter would not be considered a
slut to society. This reminded me of “Their Eyes Were Watching God” because in
this movie the protagonist, Janie, experiences a similar situation. She was
raised by her grandmother because her mother had her at a young age. In order
to avoid the same thing happening to Janie, her grandmother is very protective
of her. For example, she did not want her interacting with the boys that lived
near her. At one point she even slapped Janie after she caught her kissing a
boy. Furthermore, Janie’s grandmother forced her to marry at a young age so
that she could have financial security. In the short story, some of the
different rules mentioned included how to walk and how to smile in different
situations.
The
main connection between Girl and “Their
Eyes Were Watching God” is that the adult figure is trying to teach the
protagonist how to become a woman in society. Also both were based around a
time period where women were subjected to inequality to men. Girls during this
time were forced to grow up faster than they wanted to; in regards to the tasks
they had to do. Another connection was that the voice of both protagonists is
not heard. In Girl, the daughter
never responds back to what the mother has to say. While in “Their Eyes Were
Watching God” Janie is present, but out of respect, she obeys her grandmother’s
demands. I thought the short story was very interesting and “Their Eyes Were
Watching God” is one of my favorite movies and books!
The connections you have made here are great. Although I have never seen this movie I can still see the great comparisons between "Girl" and "Their Eyes Were Watching God". Both of the girls in the movie and the short story had an adult figure that wanted them to be almost the "perfect" young lady in society. They did not want the girls to make the decisions that they felt would be wrong as well as wanting them to act, dress, and do things in society in a particular way. Also, great way of seeing how neither girl had a voice that was heard. So great comparisons with these two.
ReplyDelete